Discontinuities of a real function

December 28, 2022

Let $f\colon\R\to\R$ be a real function. Then, $f$ is continuous at $a$ if and only if for all $\varepsilon>0$, there exists a $\delta>0$ such that $|f(x)-f(a)|<\varepsilon$ for all $x$ with $|x-a|<\delta$. Our task today is to investigate the discontinuities of $f$, i.e. the set $D(f)$ of points at which $f$ is not continuous. Specifically, we want to answer two questions:

1. What type of set can $D(f)$ be?

2. Given any set $A$, is there a function $f$ that is discontinuous exactly on $A$?

Back and forth

We first need to know what it means for $f$ to be discontinuous at a point. By negating the definition of continuity, we can deduce that

The definition should make sense to you: it says that as we zoom in closer to $a$, the function $f$ stops getting closer to $f(a)$ at some point, instead staying outside a "barrier" around $f(a)$.

Given a set $I$, the oscillation of $f$ on $I$ is

The geometric meaning of the oscillation is hopefully clear. Note that the oscillation is always nonnegative, and if $J\subset I$, then $\omega(f;J)\le\omega(f;I)$. Thus, as $I$ "shrinks" toward $a$, the oscillation $\omega(f;I)$ decreases to some nonnegative limit. We can now define the oscillation of $f$ at $a$ by

If $\omega(f;I)$ is how much $f$ "jumps" on the set $I$, then $\omega_f(a)$ is how much $f$ jumps at $a$. The definition (*) above can be rewritten into

We can now conclude that $f$ is discontinuous at $a$ if and only if $\omega_f(a)>0$.

Open sesame

The preceding observation allows us to write $D(f)$ as the set of $a$ for which $\omega_f(a)>0$. We need one final detail.

Lemma. For any $r>0$, the set $\{a\colon\omega_f(a)< r\}$ is open.

Proof. Given $a$ such that $\omega_f(a)<r$, there is a bounded interval $I$ containing $a$ such that $\omega(f;I)<r$. Consequently, $I$ is a subset of $\{a\colon\omega_f(a)< r\}$, since for any $x\in I$, we have $\omega_f(x)\le\omega(f; I)<r$. $\square$

With this lemma, we can finally prove a characterization of $D(f)$.

Theorem. $D(f)$ is the countable union of closed sets in $\R$.

Proof. The first part of this characterization is easy enough:

The complement of $\{a\colon \omega_f(a)\ge 1/n\}$ is $\{a\colon \omega_f(a)< 1/n\}$, which is open. Thus, $D(f)$ is a countable union of closed sets. $\square$

This result holds in a general metric space. In a topological space, a countable union of closed sets is called an $F_\sigma$ set.¹ We now know that $D(f)$ is an $F_\sigma$ set, but is every $F_\sigma$ set a $D(f)$ for some $f$?

The imitation game

The answer to the question above is "yes": any $F_\sigma$ set in $\R$ is the set of discontinuities for some function $f$. We shall construct $f$ by trying to follow the characterization in our proof of the major theorem in the previous section.

Theorem. If $E$ is an $F_\sigma$ set in $\R$, there is some $f\colon\R\to\R$ such that $E=D(f)$.

Proof. Let $E=\bigcup_{i=1}^\infty F_i$, where each $F_i$ is closed. Let $E_1=F_1$ and

Note that the $E_n$ are disjoint, $\bigcup_{n=1}^m E_n = \bigcup_{n=1}^m F_n$, and $\bigcup_{n=1}^\infty E_n = E$. Each $E_n$ has a countable dense subset $D_n$ (see later). We now define $f$ on $\R$ as follows:

The function is well-defined since $\R\setminus E$ and the $E_n$ are mutually disjoint. We now consider some $x\in\R$.

Suppose $x\in E$, then $x\in E_n$ for some $n$.

• If $x\in E_n\setminus D_n$, then any open interval containing $x$ contains some $y\in D_n$, as $D_n$ is dense in $E_n$, in which case we have $|f(x)-f(y)|=2^{-n}$.
• If $x\in D_n$, any open interval containing $x$ contains a point $y$ outside $D_n$, since $D_n$ is countable. This point $y$ can be in $E_n\setminus D_n$ ($f(y)=2^{-n}$), or in $\R\setminus E$ ($f(y)=0$), or in some $E_k$ different from $E_n$, in which case we can pick another point in $D_k$ instead ($f(y)=2^{-k+1}$).

In any case, we can always find a point $y$ in this interval such that $|f(x)-f(y)|\ge 2^{-n}$. Altogether, if $x\in E_n$, then $\omega_f(x)\ge 2^{-n}>0$, so $f$ is discontinuous at $x$.

Suppose $x\in \R\setminus E$. For all integer $m>0$, the set $A_m=\bigcup_{n=1}^m E_n=\bigcup_{n=1}^m F_n$ is closed and does not contain $x$. For any positive integer $N$, $\R\setminus A_N$ is open, so there is an open interval $(x-r,x+r)$ disjoint from $A_N$, in which case the interval only contains points in $\R\setminus E$ or in $E_k$ with $k>N$. Hence, for any $y$ with $|x-y|<r$, we have $|f(x)-f(y)|\le 2^{-N}$, and since $N$ is arbitrary, this means the oscillation of $f$ at $x$ is zero. Thus, $f$ is continuous at $x$, and we conclude $D(f)=E$. $\square$

There is one detail we need to work out, and that is each $E_n$ has a countable dense subset, i.e. it is separable. Luckily for us, a subset of a separable metric space is always separable, and $\R$ is indeed separable, so $E_n$ is separable too. This detail will be left an exercise for the reader. After that, it should not be difficult to see that this theorem holds for any separable metric space, not just the reals, and the proof is mostly analogous.

To recap, we answer the two questions put forth from the beginning of the post:

1. What type of set can $D(f)$ be?

   It must be a countable union of closed sets, in other words, an $F_\sigma$ set.

2. Given any set $A$, is there a function $f$ that is discontinuous exactly on $A$?

   In a separable metric space $M$, for any $F_\sigma$ set, there is a function $f\colon M\to M$ whose $D(f)$ is that set.

Footnotes

1. $F$ here stands for the French word fermé, meaning closed, while the $\sigma$ means a "sum" of sets, i.e. a union. ↩